Stepping Up to the Plate: Example of an AI Policy Checklist

November 17, 2026

In our previous post in this series, we discussed why a practical AI policy checklist matters and considerations for ensuring the checklist addresses the needs of the organization over time.

As we noted in the last post, an AI policy checklist’s greatest value is requiring users to establish what is permitted, who is responsible, what must be verified, and when to stop and seek guidance. Still, it can be difficult to get started with a checklist that’s comprehensive and flexible. In this post, we’ll provide an example checklist that can provide ideas for your organization to develop its own checklist.

Example AI Policy Checklist  Download the template

Note: This is a proposed operational template of an AI policy checklist for law firms and corporate legal departments, not a statement that every item is legally required in every jurisdiction. Adapt it to applicable professional-conduct rules, law, court orders, contracts, and client instructions.

Completion record

Information Required Details
Organization
Matter or Department
Proposed AI Task
Tool, Feature, and Model
Account or Tenant
Data Involved
Responsible Lawyer
Review Date
Next Review Date

 

Checklist Item Record

Complete this record for each checklist item.

Status Owner Supporting Record Date
☐ Yes  ☐ No  ☐ Not Applicable
☐ Yes  ☐ No  ☐ Not Applicable
☐ Yes  ☐ No  ☐ Not Applicable

 

Decision Rules

Requirement Direction
Not Applicable Responses Explain every “Not Applicable” response.
Unresolved Requirements If a mandatory requirement remains unresolved, pause the affected AI use.
Internal Exceptions Identify the named approver, written rationale, safeguards, and expiration or reassessment date.
Limits on Exceptions Internal exceptions cannot override applicable law, professional-conduct rules, court orders, contractual obligations, or client restrictions.

 

 

  1. Scope and ownership — policy owner / general counsel
  • Cover lawyers, employees, contract reviewers, consultants, and service providers using AI for organizational work.
  • Include standalone tools, embedded features, meeting assistants, browser extensions, integrations, and autonomous agents.
  • Name the policy owner, approval contacts, incident contact, and lawyer accountable for each legal workflow.
  • Classify uses as permitted, conditionally permitted, or prohibited; provide concrete examples.
  • Set review dates and triggers for reassessment after material changes.
  1. Approved tools — IT / security / procurement
  • Verify approval for the exact product, feature, account type, configuration, data category, and intended task.
  • Record approved integrations and underlying providers; separately assess new connectors or autonomous capabilities.
  • Review contractual terms covering training, secondary use, retention, deletion, support access, subprocessors, data location, and incident notification.
  • Prohibit unapproved accounts for work data and provide an accessible request process for new tools.
  • Test the intended workflow with authorized test data before live deployment.
  1. Client instructions and consent — responsible lawyer
  • Review engagement terms, outside counsel guidelines, client instructions, and matter-specific restrictions.
  • Determine separately whether client notification, consultation, or informed consent is required; document the basis.
  • When consent is required, explain the intended use, information involved, material risks, benefits, safeguards, and reasonable alternatives.
  • Obtain consent from an authorized client representative before the covered use; record its scope and conditions.
  • Reassess permission when the tool, data, use, or material risks change; do not treat generic engagement language as sufficient for every use.
  1. Confidential information — responsible lawyer / privacy lead
  • Identify client-related information, privileged material, work product, personal information, trade secrets, and material governed by protective orders.
  • Verify authority to process each category and determine whether the proposed transfer is consistent with privilege protections and other restrictions.
  • Minimize inputs and assess re-identification risk when using redaction or pseudonyms.
  • Restrict uploads, prompts, connected repositories, and retrieved content to the approved matter and purpose.
  • Apply appropriate protection to outputs, chat histories, logs, and shared links as well as inputs.
  1. Security and access — security / system administrator
  • Configure organizational accounts, strong authentication, least-privilege access, and appropriate encryption.
  • Test matter boundaries, ethical walls, sharing permissions, and connector access using representative user accounts.
  • Verify actual training, retention, logging, export, and deletion settings against the approved configuration.
  • Assess malicious instructions in documents or websites and unauthorized data transfers through connected tools.
  • Establish procedures to revoke access, disable a feature, and suspend an agent promptly.
  1. Human review and eDiscovery validation — supervising lawyer / review lead
  • Define the authorized task, evaluation criteria, review checkpoints, and escalation conditions before use.
  • Verify legal authorities, quotations, and material factual assertions against authoritative sources before relying on them.
  • For document classification, define sampling and validation methods that assess both incorrect inclusions and missed material.
  • Test privilege and sensitive-data handling separately; define human review for uncertain or consequential decisions.
  • Record relevant model/configuration information, evaluation results, errors, corrective actions, and approval; revalidate after material changes.
  • Require lawyer authorization before filings, productions, substantive external advice, or other consequential external actions.
  1. Billing and expenses — billing lawyer / finance
  • Confirm the fee arrangement and applicable client billing restrictions.
  • For hourly work, record actual reasonable time spent; exclude hypothetical time saved and unattended machine processing.
  • Describe prompting, analysis, verification, and revision accurately in time entries.
  • Keep general AI training and ordinary overhead out of matter charges under the organization’s policy.
  • Review proposed AI expenses for contractual authorization, applicable ethics limits, allocation, and duplicate recovery.
  • Review flat or alternative fees for reasonableness; document agreed scope and expense treatment.
  1. Disclosure requirements — matter lawyer
  • Check applicable statutes, professional rules, court rules, standing orders, case orders, and discovery agreements.
  • Record separately any disclosure owed to the client, court, opposing counsel, regulator, or another recipient.
  • Assign responsibility for the required content, timing, method, and supporting verification.
  • Confirm that any certification accurately describes the AI use and review actually performed.
  • Review disclosures for confidentiality and privilege issues; seek appropriate relief when duties conflict.
  • Recheck requirements when the forum, judge, workflow, or governing instructions change.
  1. Records and preservation — records / eDiscovery lead
  • Identify prompts, responses, source references, versions, action logs, approvals, and validation records necessary for the matter.
  • Apply documented retention schedules and applicable legal holds; avoid indiscriminate saving or deletion.
  • Test preservation and export of relevant AI records, including records held by providers.
  • Protect records according to their content; obtain legal review before asserting privilege or producing them.
  1. Training, incidents, and monitoring — policy owner
  • Train users with role-specific examples before access and after significant changes.
  • Require providers and contract reviewers to follow applicable AI restrictions and disclose material workflow changes.
  • Give users a clear route for reporting unauthorized uploads, erroneous outputs, and unexpected agent actions.
  • Preserve incident evidence, contain the problem, assess impact, and assign legal review of notification or correction duties.
  • Periodically sample actual usage and completed checklists; address recurring gaps and record remediation.

Decision

Decision Record Selection / Details
Approval status ☐ Approved  ☐ Approved with conditions  ☐ Not approved
Conditions, unresolved issues, or internal exception reference
Approving lawyer or relevant technical owner
Date and reassessment trigger

 

Conclusion

While every organization has different considerations and different jurisdictional and reporting requirements, this AI policy checklist can provide a practical starting point for developing one that fits your organization.

Ready to put these principles into practice? Download our sample AI Policy Checklist to help your team document AI use, responsibilities, approvals, and review requirements. Next time, we’ll discuss practical validation methodologies for legal AI workflows. For more regarding Cimplifi specialized expertise regarding AI & machine learning, click here.

Download the template

Schedule a live, personalized demo with Cimplifi today or click here to learn more about Maestro.